The Costs of Consolidation:

Arguments and Evidence for Blocking the Paramount-Warner Bros. Merger

Decades of mergers and acquisitions have reduced the number of major U.S. media companies to a handful of transnational conglomerates that dominate the production and circulation of news, film, television, sports, games, and other forms of media and culture. If Paramount Skydance acquires Warner Bros. Discovery, not only will this newly-formed conglomerate be burdened with $79 billion of debt, it will struggle to respect competitive safeguards, serve consumer needs, cultivate the media industry’s long term health, and act in the broader interest of the public. 

A team of more than 20 media experts from universities across the U.S. and Canada have collaborated on this research to encourage the courts, government regulators, non-governmental organizations, legislators, and citizens to challenge this deal. While this study addresses some of the quantitative impacts of this potential merger, our scope is far wider. The fourrteen sections of this study define consumer welfare, public interest, and healthy competition more broadly, and consider democratic objectives like fair media access for non-profit and public-serving organizations, the preservation of community cultural spaces like theaters and of community social events like sports, and the support of a diverse range of stories and storytellers. Having spent decades researching the many (often non-quantifiable) ways that media and culture shape our lives as citizens and individuals, we enumerate here what kinds of impacts we can expect from this deal, and why policymakers and the public should be so concerned. 

Download the report as a pdf (2.8 MB) or read each section below

Table of Contents

AUTHORS

Andrew deWaardAssociate Professor of Communication, UC San Diego
Shawna KidmanAssociate Professor of Communication, UC San Diego
Miranda BanksProfessor of Film, TV, & Media Studies, Loyola Marymount University
Pete JohnsonVisiting Assistant Professor, Gallatin School, New York University
Rodney BensonProfessor of Media, Culture, & Communication, New York University
Cale EppsPhD Student, Cinema & Media Studies, University of Southern California
James FleurySenior Lecturer in Film and Media Studies, Washington University
Kate FortmuellerAssociate Professor of Film and Media History, Georgia State University
Dawn FratiniLecturer in Animation, Loyola Marymount University
Michael GaineyPhD Student, Communication, University of California San Diego
Jennifer HesslerAssistant Professor of Cinematic Arts, University of Southern California
Pete KunzeAssistant Professor of Communication, Tulane University
Deborah JaramilloProfessor of Film & Television Studies, Boston University
Annemarie Navar-GillAssistant Professor of Communication, Old Dominion University
Charlotte OrzelVisiting Assistant Professor of Communication, Tulane University
Karen PetruskaAssociate Professor of Communication Studies, Gonzaga University
Pawel PopielAssistant Professor of Communication, Washington State University
Jennifer PorstAssociate Professor of Film & Media, Emory University
Michael ReinhardVisiting Assistant Professor of Film & Media, Emory University
Alex RussoOrdinary Professor of Media & Communication and History, Catholic University
Christine SmithAssociate Librarian, Concordia University Library
Ethan TusseyAssociate Professor of Film & Media, Georgia State University
Caleb WardPhD Student, Film & Media, Georgia State University